discbine hype vs sickle reality

[Grafh_Seeker]

Everybody hypes discbines like they're the only way to cut hay, but I'm not convinced they're worth it unless you're mowing huge acres or running custom. My fields are 10 acres, rocky in spots, and I cut just for myself. Dealer wants my old JD 720 MOCO for $1250 toward a new machine, but those discbines aren't cheap... and hitting rocks with one isn't my idea of fun.

Truth is, sickle machines are still everywhere and cost next to nothing. For the way I run, I'm not sure shaving a little time off each cut justifies dropping that kind of cash. Anyone else stick with sickle machines in 2025 and not feel like you're missing out? Or did making the jump to a discbine actually change your whole haying game?

 

[hayderre23]

I still use a sickle mower on my 12-acre field, it's rocky in places like yours. And it works just fine. I tried a neighbor's discbine once, and it was quicker, but too pricey and risky for me. I keep the blades sharp and take my time, and I've never felt behind. If your JD 720 still cuts well, I'd say stick with it.

 

[calypso]

I'm in the same boat..... 10 ish acres, some rocky spots, and I stick with my old sickle bar mower. Its been cheap, easy to maintain, and I'm not missing the speed of a discbine at all

 

[Full3r]

I’m still running a sickle machine on a similar setup and honestly don’t feel behind too. Maintenance is cheap, and I’d rather swap a guard than a set of discbine blades after hitting rocks. The way I see things, the time savings just don’t justify the cost

 

[labrvnth10]

10 to 12 acres, rocky spots. Honestly, for small scale cutting, it does the job and keeps from worrying about hitting rocks. dont run one but I can relate well